How to Know If Your Therapist Is a Good Fit

Therapy plays a pivotal role in helping individuals navigate the complexities of life, offering support...

Coping Skills
May 23, 2025

Therapy plays a pivotal role in helping individuals navigate the complexities of life, offering support during challenging times and providing tools to manage mental health effectively. It can be a transformative journey of coping skills, self-discovery, healing, and growth. However, the success of this therapeutic journey largely hinges on finding the right therapist - a professional who not only possesses the requisite knowledge and skills but also resonates with you on a personal level. The significance of this match cannot be overstated; a good rapport with your therapist can foster a safe, trusting environment that encourages open communication and facilitates meaningful progress.

You Feel Comfortable Sharing With Them

Your comfort level during therapy sessions is a telling sign of a strong therapeutic alliance. It's reflected in how relaxed you feel while discussing everything from your day-to-day life to deeper emotional issues. Many therapists use active listening techniques to foster such an environment. For example, you might notice yourself comfortably discussing past traumas, anxieties, ambitions, or even negative therapy experiences. The absence of fear of being judged or misunderstood is crucial here. This level of comfort is deeply tied with trust - a fundamental element in any therapeutic experience.

Here are some examples you might be feeling.

  • You don't feel judged when discussing your sexual orientation, belief system, or mental illness.
  • You feel a meaningful change after the first session.
  • You and your therapist are on the same page regarding your therapy experience and goals.
  • Even when you start therapy feeling worse, the therapist helps you see progress.
  • There are no signs of unethical behaviors from the therapist.

Trusting your therapist involves believing they are trustworthy, have your best interests at heart, and will handle your vulnerabilities with care. Most therapists strive to build this trust as it's central to their job, especially if you need counseling for feeling emotionally overwhelmed. A particular intervention may not suit everyone. Therefore, the right therapist should be able to offer resources and alternatives tailored to your specific needs. For instance, if you're treating depression, the therapist's ability to adjust their approach based on your progress is essential. The journey to personal growth often begins with seeking treatment from a mental health professional. Recognizing the right person to guide you through this process can be challenging. A key indicator that your particular therapist is a good match is when you feel at ease sharing your innermost thoughts, feelings, and experiences with them. It's this trust that allows for open dialogue, encourages honesty, and ultimately, fosters healing and growth.

They Respect Your Boundaries

Boundaries could include the length and time of sessions, rules for scheduling, clarity about fees, and limits on personal disclosure and touch. A therapist respecting these boundaries is a key sign of a good fit. You can identify if your therapist respects your boundaries if they adhere to the agreed-upon rules and guidelines, avoid excessive self-disclosure, respect your comfort zone, and ensure that their actions and conversations remain within the professional context. Additionally, a good therapist should encourage you to express your needs and assert your boundaries, fostering a safe, respectful, and healthy therapeutic environment.

They Show Empathy and Understanding

Empathy in therapy is akin to a warm embrace, where your therapist truly understands and shares your feelings. This could manifest in several ways: they might mirror your emotions subtly, validating your experiences without overshadowing them; they might articulate your feelings when you struggle to find the words, demonstrating their deep understanding of your emotional state; or they might simply listen attentively, offering silent solidarity. For example, if you're recounting a particularly painful memory, an empathic therapist might acknowledge your pain with phrases like "That sounds really hard" or "I can see why you'd feel upset about this." They might also show understanding by remembering important details from your previous sessions or by acknowledging the strength it took for you to share your story. In essence, empathy in therapy looks like feeling seen, heard, and understood on a profound level.

They Challenge You in a Constructive Way

Therapists may employ a variety of styles to challenge clients, ranging from robust-confrontative to gentle-empathic. For instance, they might use the technique of cognitive restructuring to help you identify and challenge unhelpful thought patterns, or employ constructive confrontation to highlight incongruences and conflicts in your process. A therapist might also gently push back when a client consistently changes topics to avoid uncomfortable subjects. Importantly, these challenges are always balanced with empathy and respect for the client's comfort level. The goal is not to create discomfort but to foster an environment where clients can safely step out of their comfort zones and engage in meaningful self-exploration and growth.

You Are Making Progress With Them

Identifying progress in therapy can be a deeply personal and unique experience, as it varies greatly depending on individual goals and timelines. Progress may manifest as increased self-awareness, improved emotional regulation, a decrease in symptoms of stress or anxiety, or positive changes in relationships. It might also look like acquiring new coping mechanisms and applying them in real-life situations, or achieving set therapeutic goals. You might notice that you're thinking differently about problems, reacting differently to triggers, or feeling more confident and at ease. Essentially, if you're feeling better, functioning better, or finding more satisfaction in your life, it's a good indication that you're making progress with your therapist.

How to Address Concerns with Your Therapist

If you have concerns about your therapy process, it's crucial to voice these to your therapist. You could start by expressing your feelings directly and honestly during your session, ensuring to use "I" statements to avoid sounding accusatory. For instance, "I feel uncomfortable when..." or "I don't feel I'm making progress because...". Your therapist should be open to feedback and willing to adjust their approach to better suit your needs. If, despite your efforts, the issues persist or your therapist reacts defensively, it might be time to consider finding a new therapist. This decision is deeply personal and should be made based on your comfort level, the quality of the therapeutic relationship, and your progress toward your mental health goals.

Conclusion

Finding the right fit with a therapist is not just important, but crucial for your mental health journey. A good therapist should make you feel comfortable, respected, and understood while maintaining professional boundaries and helping you make progress. If you're experiencing any red flags, it's essential to communicate your concerns openly or consider seeking a new therapist. Prioritizing your mental health is an act of self-care and self-respect. Don't settle for less than what you need - finding the right therapist might take time and patience, but it's worth the effort for the positive impact it can have on your life.

Author
Jennifer Luttman, LPC, ACS

I am a Licensed Professional Counselor, and owner of Overcomers Counseling. I'm dedicated to helping individuals find strength and healing through life’s challenges. With a deep understanding of mental health and years of professional experience, I specialize in fostering hope and resilience while equipping her clients with tools to thrive. Passionate about empowering others, she creates a safe, supportive space where everyone feels seen, valued, and capable of overcoming obstacles on their path to well-being.

Common Questions about Coping Skills

How can I adapt to stressors?

You can adapt to stressors and new situations by looking at the big picture, focusing on the positive, reframing problems, and adjusting your standards when necessary. Setting reasonable standards is a surefire way to avoid unnecessary anxiety.

When should I seek professional help for my emotional overwhelm?

If your feelings of emotional overwhelm persist despite your efforts to cope, or if they begin to negatively impact your daily functioning, relationships, or overall well-being, it's important to seek professional help from a mental health professional such as a therapist or counselor.

Potential Consequences if Someone Doesn't Address Their Emotional Overwhelm

  • Increased risk of mental health disorders, such as anxiety and depression
  • Strained relationships due to poor emotional regulation and communication
  • Reduced productivity and job satisfaction as a result of chronic stress
  • Lower overall well-being and life satisfaction

What are unhealthy self-soothing strategies and behaviors?

Some examples of self-soothing strategies that are not healthy include binge-watching TV, emotional eating, drinking alcohol, compulsive gambling, obsessive game-playing, and constant internet surfing.

What is a life coaching course?

A life coaching course is an online program that helps individuals achieve their personal and professional goals through structured guidance and advice. It offers tools and strategies to help you identify areas of improvement, set clear objectives, and build a personalized plan for success.

What does a typical life coaching course look like?

A typical course consists of modules or lessons that cover topics such as goal setting, decision-making skills, problem-solving techniques, communication strategies, stress management techniques, mindfulness practices, etc. Each module will also offer assignments or exercises designed to help you move closer to achieving your goals.

How does a typical mental health life coaching session go?

A typical mental health life coaching session typically starts with setting an agenda based on the client's goals. The coach and client then discuss various topics that are related to the client's goals, such as identifying challenges, building self-awareness, developing new skills, and identifying strategies for overcoming obstacles. During the session, the coach provides guidance and feedback to help the client reach their desired outcome.